Tony Grist (poliphilo) wrote,
Tony Grist

Alice Revisited

Ask me to name a favourite book and I'll probably say Alice in Wonderland- but up until yesterday I hadn't read it in decades.

What an anxious book it is.  First we're anxious about our identity- am I Alice or Mabel? Then we're anxious about abandonment- all alone at the bottom of the well. Then we're anxious about the body- all that stretching and shrinking. Then we're anxious about causing offence- to the Mouse, to the Caterpillar.Then we're anxious about physical violence- as the plates fly at the Duchess's house. Then we're anxious about the sudden comings and goings of the Cheshire Cat,  who- in an disturbing combination- is both the friendliest of the Wonderland creatures and the eeriest. Finally we're anxious about authority- as we encounter the monstrous Queen of Hearts.  As a child I found it all a bit unsettling,  but not unbearably so, because I took my cue from Alice herself- from her remarkable courage and commonsense.   

What a wise book it is.

Was Lewis Carroll a paedophile? No, I don't think he was.  He loved children the way Wordsworth and Blake loved children- because he was a romantic, and admired their openness and freedom from cant- that quality we misleadingly call "innocence".  There's nothing creepy in his regard for Alice. He looks up to her; she's his hero; he hangs out with her because he knows she can teach him things.
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.