Tony Grist (poliphilo) wrote,
Tony Grist

The Mystery Of Edwin Drood

A curious thing about the Mystery of Edwin Drood is that it isn't particularly mysterious. 

Dickens dropped enough clues in the completed half to make the solution obvious. Drood is dead and Jasper bang to rights.

Unless, of course, the clues are red herrings- or more subtly misleading.

Nothing in Dickens' earlier work suggests he would ever have been able to misdirect his readers with the skill of a 20th century detective story writer.

But with Drood he was trying something new. He guarded the plot scrupulously-  leaving no notes, confiding in no-one, getting jumpy when he thought his illustrator, Luke Fildes, was guessing too well.  Everything suggests that this was to be the first of his books in which plot really mattered.

So could there be another mystery underlying the murder mystery? Something to do with Jasper's backstory, perhaps?

We'll never know.

But Drood is more than just an unfinished detective story. There are many new beginnings. Dickens is extending his range-  the ecclesiastical setting, the opium smoking,  the interest in Empire and race. He was tired and sick and failing, but not as an artist. The brokenness of Drood is a crying shame not just because we'll never know the ending but because it was shaping up to be a very great book.

  • On Mature Reflection

    I dreamed I'd co-authored a book about how I came to leave the Church. I was leafing through the finished article and finding it very glum. My…

  • Earworms And Rain

    Binge-listening to variant versions of Matty Groves/Little Musgrave means I now have it as an ear worm. It could be worse; it could be the Birdy…

  • Matty Groves

    I'm sure there's a version where the husband cuts his wife's head off and kicks it against the wall but I can't find it. Did I make…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.