Tony Grist (poliphilo) wrote,
Tony Grist

Dr Zhivago

I didn't care for Dr Zhivago when it first came out; I thought it slow to the point of dreariness and distinctly old fashioned. Also emotionally detached.  Fifty years on (and more) slow has become meditative, old-fashioned has become timeless- and emotional detachment no longer seems such a bad thing.

In fact I can't see much wrong with it. The performances are great. I'd loved to have seen James Mason as Komarovsky (he turned it down) which isn't to say that Rod Steiger isn't more than adequate. Chaplin is sweet, Sharif is soulful, Christie does a wonderful job of turning a dream girl into something real, Guinness is miscast but has his moments and Richardson is a joy. Klaus Kinski puts in a characteristic appearance being dangerous and mad. Russia (actually Spain and Finland and other far-flung places) looks beautiful.

I don't suppose there's any doubt now that Lean is one of the great directors.

I read the book around the time I saw the movie- in a cheap paperback edition with Sharif and Christie and a steam train on the cover- and found it a slog- an attempt to do something Tolstoyan by a writer who wasn't really a novelist. The cheerleaders of the west wanted it to be an enduring classic because it was a wet fish to slap the Soviets with- but I doubt they were right.  Do people still read it? I suppose it's of historic interest and importance. Am I going to re-read it? No. But I'd happily watch the film again.

Recent Posts from This Journal

  • So That's All Right Then

    Jeremy Corbyn is a man of principle- and as near incorruptible as any politician ever is. Had he become prime minister he would have annoyed the…

  • One Of Those Days

    You haven't posted anything yet..." says Ailz. "No" I say. "it's been one of those days." Overcast, wet,…

  • Little Nell

    I wish Little Nell didn't weep so much. For Dickens weeping is attractive and engaging. It shows heart. And all his supposedly sympathetic…

  • Irrational

    I look at the trees and think, "Come on, get a move on, drop your leaves. Let's get this winter over and done with..."

  • By Heart

    The only time that I can think of that I actually sat down and committed verse to memory was when my grandmother offered me a reward if I did…

  • Going, Going

    By the time I'd sorted through all the drawers I'd filled a big cardboard box with papers to burn. There have been sunny intervals today…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.