||[Apr. 3rd, 2015|10:33 am]
No-one fell on their face. No-one triumphed. Here's how I thought they all did.|
David Cameron: He seemed tired. He has the gravitas of office and a record to defend. What can he promise apart from more of the same? He didn't attempt to get us excited.
Ed Miliband: The camera doesn't love him. And he doesn't love the camera. You can see the cogs whirring before he decides to smile or turn his head. Full frontal he looks like a currant bun, in profile ( he should do this more often) he looks like a Roman emperor.) It's hard to pay attention to what he's saying when one's waiting for him to cross his eyes or trip over his laces.
Nick Clegg: Nick is still awfully good at this sort of thing. You might almost mistake him for one of us instead of one of them. But he's yesterday's man. His party are going to lose most of their seats- including (most probably) his own. It would have made no difference if his contributions had been replaced by a bar or two of soothing music. No-one agrees with him any more.
Nigel Farage: Farage is as odd-looking as Miliband but knows how to work the face. He's like a monkey on a stick. Whatever question he was asked he managed to work his answer round to immigration. It gets tired. And at times- when he started on foreigners with HIV- downright nasty.
Nicola Sturgeon: Alex Salmond was the most charismatic politician in Britain and now Nicola is. She's sharp, natty, and red as sunrise over the Clyde. If the ScotNats have that extra fizz it's because they actually believe in something. She seems poised to turf Labour out of Scotland and if she does she'll be a power in Westminster as well. On last night's showing that seems like a throughly good idea. I wish I could vote for her.
Leanne Wood: Every so often this little voice piped up and talked about Wales. The Scots Nats are a power in the land, Plaid Cymru are barely a power in Wales. One wonders how they got a pass into this august assembly when none of the parties of Northern Ireland did.
Natalie Bennett: Natalie reminded us that there are things at stake apart from the economy and the NHS. Global warming and little furry animals for instance. For this reason she'd get my vote. She comes with a reputation for amateurism but she talked tough and looked hard.
But the main thing is there were seven of them. Seven party leaders on stage together has never happened before. It signals a profound change in British politics: the end of the era of two (or lets be kind, three) party domination.
Seven podiums on a stage- each one lit a different colour- orange, purple, red, blue, yellow, two shades of green. It's going to be one of the iconic images of the 21st century...
Iconic indeed. Perhaps a way forward for politics to be contributory rather than confrontational. We;;.i hope so.
Early days, but we'll see. It's hard to be confrontational when there are seven of you.
Rather beautifully written. ^_^ Indeed, Miliband comes off as about as spontaneous as a presidential motorcade. I really, really hope there are party activists working within to restore Labour to being a party of the people, not a slightly prettier brand of the Conservatives.
I'm dreadfully disappointed to see the press are, apparently, still in love with Farage, and still almost as unlikely to even mention Natalie Bennett. When I scanned down the Guardian's coverage today, I wasn't sure the Greens had even been represented there.
Overall, would you say it'd be worth watching? (We missed it here - were watching Into the Woods, which we both agreed was an entertaining enough film, but neither of us were particularly taken by any of the musical numbers)
Farage gave us his usual schtick- and showed up his limitations. He has only one policy and it's an ugly one.
I don't think you'll learn anything much from watching the debate. I don't believe I did. The one revelation was Nicola Sturgeon. She was very impressive.
Your candidates sound so much more interesting than ours, which are more like idiot, idiot, idiot, preacher, troll, idiot, loser.
Perhaps. I think it's fair to say that none of our lot are fools.
I hope you don't mind, I've been reading your posts, I find them interesting.
I'm very pleased to have you reading. This is an open blog.
Nick Clegg won't lose his seat - and neither will Charles Kennedy and assorted other LibDems that Ashcroft thinks are doomed.
If most charismatic = 'most full of himself', then yes, Alex Salmond was that. (See also 'gorgeous' George Galloway.) The SNP are left-wing, unshock. I was surprised none of the others called her on her free tuition line: it's not free in Scotland if you're from the rest of the UK.
Of the two other women, one started off being challenged to say 'Plaid Cymru' as often as she could and the other will never recover from that radio interview.
But outside them, it's a horrible choice.