Tony Grist (poliphilo) wrote,
Tony Grist

The Winter Ghosts: Kate Mosse

A mash-up of Great War misery memoir, pre-Raphaelite romance (our medieval heroine is described as looking like a painting by Waterhouse), colour-supplement Francophilia  and tweedy traditional ghost story, with stock characters, a faltering sense of period, cliches by the gross and a long-delayed climax you could spot coming about a third of the way through. I lost faith in Mosse when she told me she was a fan of the traditional English ghost story and then identified Le Fanu as an Edwardian. She left me feeling that if you want to write a run-away bestseller you must- at all costs- avoid doing anything to surprise the reader.

Before I read this- and thinking I was going to enjoy it- I made the mistake of investing (not very heavily) in a copy of Mosse's first novel- the huge, tomey Labyrinth (even her titles are secondhand.) It will now be going straight back to the charity shop. 

  • I Am He As You Are He As You Are Me And We Are All Together

    I dreamed I was one of the Beatles I was at Paul's house, and he was being very high-handed and getting on my nerves, so I went down to the…

  • Hearing Things.

    I dreamed I'd decided to walk home (wherever home was) along the south coast, starting at a town pretending to be Bexhill but actually…

  • They Chose The Losing Side

    I got into a debate about the pandemic this morning. It's something I do my best to avoid because the issue is so divisive- and the…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.